Medical Study #1

Am J Gastroenterol. 1992 Nov;87(11):1600-6

Optimal nonsurgical treatment of hemorrhoids: a comparative analysis of infrared coagulation, rubber band ligation, and injection sclerotherapy.

Johanson JF, Rimm A. Department of Medicine, University of Illinois College of Medicine, Rockford.

Despite an abundance of nonsurgical hemorrhoid therapies, none has been consistently more efficacious. By combining data from multiple clinical trials in a meta-analysis, the present study compared the efficacy and complications of infrared coagulation, injection sclerotherapy, and rubber band ligation to determine the optimal nonoperative hemorrhoid treatment. All published clinical trials comparing the three methods were identified by computer search and review of appropriate English language journals.

Five trials studying 863 patients satisfied all inclusion criteria. Results demonstrated that similar numbers of patients were asymptomatic 12 months after treatment, regardless of initial therapy. However, significantly fewer patients undergoing rubber band ligation required additional treatment because symptoms had recurred. Although rubber band ligation demonstrated greater long-term efficacy, it was associated with a significantly higher incidence of posttreatment pain.

In contrast, infrared coagulation was associated with both fewer and less severe complications. Thus, when all factors are considered, infrared coagulation may in fact be the optimal nonoperative hemorrhoid treatment.

Medical Study #2

Eur J Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2000 May;12(5):535-9

A randomized controlled trial of rubber band ligation versus infra-red coagulation in the treatment of internal haemorrhoids.

Poen AC, Felt-Bersma RJ, Cuesta MA, Devillé W, Meuwissen SG. Department of Surgery, Academic Hospital Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.

OBJECTIVE:Despite the presence of numerous non-surgical therapies for the treatment of haemorrhoids, none of these therapies has clearly been proven to be superior. The effectiveness and patient tolerance of rubber band ligation (RBL) and infra-red coagulation (IRC) in the treatment of haemorrhoids was assessed.

DESIGN: Prospective randomized trial.

SETTING: Academic hospital (tertiary care).

PARTICIPANTS: A total of 133 consecutive patients (73 males, 60 females, mean age 48 years (range 19-82)) with internal haemorrhoids, and without concomitant anorectal disease, were randomized to rubber band ligation (RBL, n = 65) or infra-red coagulation (IRC, n = 68).

INTERVENTIONS: Rubber band ligation or infra-red coagulation was performed in one or more sessions with four-week intervals until symptoms had resolved. Treatment outcome and side-effects were assessed after each treatment session and one month after the last treatment by proctological examination and a questionnaire, including a pain score (visual analogue scale from 0 to 10). Recurrence of complaints was assessed by telephone questionnaire [mean follow-up of 19.2 months (SD 7.8)].

RESULTS: Treatment outcome was assessed in 124 patients (60 RBL, 64 IRC). The mean number of treatment sessions was 1.6 (SD 0.9) for both therapies. For RBL, 58 patients (97%), and for IRC, 59 patients (92%) were symptom-free or had satisfactorily improved. Only third-degree haemorrhoids seemed to respond better to RBL (five of five patients symptom-free) than to IRC (two of four patients symptom-free). Pain following treatment was more common and more severe after RBL (VAS 5.5 +/- 3.7) than after IRC (VAS 3.3 +/- 3.3, P = 0.018).

The telephone questionnaire was answered by 105 patients. Nine of 50 patients (18%) treated with RBL and 11 of 55 patients (20%, P = 0.81) treated with IRC had experienced symptomatic relapse to pre-treatment levels.

CONCLUSIONS: Infra-red coagulation and rubber band ligation are equally effective in the treatment of haemorrhoids. The rate and severity of pain is higher after rubber band ligation. Infra-red coagulation should be the first-line treatment for haemorrhoids.

Medical Study #3

Acta Cir Bras [serial online] 2004 Jan-Feb;19(1)

Infrared coagulation: a preferred option in treating early hemorrhoids.

Gupta PJ

BACKGROUND: The ideal therapy for hemorrhoids is always debated. For early grades of the disease, many different modalities of treatment have been proposed. Some are effective but are more painful, others are less painful but their efficacy is not assured on long term. Infrared photocoagulation has emerged as a new addition to the list. In this procedure, the tissue is coagulated by infrared radiation. During treatment, mechanical pressure and radiation energy are applied simultaneously to ablate the blood supply to the hemorrhoidal mass.

METHODS: In the present retrospective study, the effect of infrared coagulation on patients with early grades of hemorrhoids is described. In a separate study, a comparison is made between Infrared coagulation and rubber band ligation in terms of their effectiveness and discomfort.

RESULTS: 212 patients were treated by infrared coagulation and were followed up for a period of 18 months. Only 28 patients had persistence or recurrence of bleeding. Overall ratio of comfort and patient satisfaction from pain and bleeding was quite satisfactory. The comparative study showed that though rubber band ligation is more effective, it is a more painful procedure.

CONCLUSION: These studies shows that Infrared coagulation for hemorrhoids in early stages could prove to be a easy and effective alternative to conventional methods as it is quick, less painful and safe. The procedure can be repeated in case of recurrence and should be considered as the first choice in early hemorrhoids.

Medical Study #4

Am J Gastroenterol. 1989 May;84(5):482-7

Direct current (Ultroid) electrotherapy of internal hemorrhoids: an effective, safe, and painless outpatient approach.

Norman DA, Newton R, Nicholas GV. University of Nevada, School of Medicine, Reno.

Hemorrhoid disease is one of the most frequently occurring, disabling conditions of man. We report the results of 120 patients with symptomatic internal and mixed hemorrhoid disease treated with direct current (d.c.) via a dual-tipped disposable needle probe (negative electrode). Evaluation and treatment utilized an operative anoscope which visualized one-eighth of the anal canal.

Five hundred ninety segments revealed hemorrhoid disease (grade 1 = 114, 2 = 222, 3 = 178, 4 = 76). One or more segments (highest grade) were treated per office visit.

Symptoms, frequency, and mean number of treatment applications per patient for complete symptom resolution were: bleeding, 85%, 4.0; protrusion, 58%, 3.9; pain, 52%, 3.6; and pruritus, 49%, 3.9. Ablation of hemorrhoid disease grade was directly correlated with milliampere current and time of application. No major complications occurred. All patients were successfully treated and remained symptom-free at a mean duration of follow-up of 23 months.

Direct current electrotherapy is an effective, painless, and safe outpatient treatment approach to all grades of internal and mixed hemorrhoid disease.